Alternative Investment Risks: What to Check Before You Buy

Alternative investments, meaning things outside ordinary stocks, bonds and cash, carry four common risks: they can be hard to sell (illiquid), expensive, complex and more exposed to fraud. Some, like crypto and collectibles, also swing sharply in price. That doesn't make every alternative a scam, but it does mean you need to check more, not less, before you commit. Any money in a high-risk alternative should be money you can afford to lose, and it should never be borrowed.
This guide wraps up our Crypto, Gold & More section with the questions that apply to every alternative. Use the checklist below whenever someone pitches you something unusual.
What counts as an alternative
The word covers a lot of ground:
- Crypto and other digital assets
- Gold, silver and other precious metals
- Rental property, private real estate deals and non-traded REITs
- Private company shares, startups and private equity
- Private loans, promissory notes and peer-to-peer lending
- Collectibles like art, wine, cars or trading cards
- Complex funds, structured products and futures
Some of these are well-regulated and widely used. Others have little oversight. The label alone tells you very little, which is why a consistent checklist helps.
The four big risks
1. Illiquidity
"Liquid" means you can turn something into cash quickly at a fair price. Many alternatives are illiquid. You may have to wait years, find a buyer yourself or accept a steep discount. That's a serious problem if life throws an emergency at you.
2. Fees
Alternatives often carry layers of costs: sales commissions, management fees, performance fees, storage, insurance and markups. They can be hard to find in the paperwork. Even small fees add up over time, and high fees mean an investment has to do well just for you to break even.
3. Complexity
If you can't explain how an investment makes money in two sentences, it's hard to judge whether it's working, or whether you're being misled. Complexity also makes it easier for a seller to hide risks.
4. Fraud
Less public information, fewer rules and big promises make alternatives a favorite setting for scams. Ponzi schemes often hide behind exotic-sounding strategies; our guide to Ponzi schemes explains how they work and why returns that seem too consistent are a warning sign.
Comparing the risks across common alternatives
| Alternative | Illiquidity | Fees | Complexity | Fraud exposure |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Crypto | Can be low on a platform, but platforms can freeze | Trading and platform fees | Medium to high | High |
| Physical metals | Medium; selling takes effort | Markups, storage | Low to medium | High in some sales channels |
| Rental property | High | Buying and selling costs, upkeep | Medium | Medium |
| Non-traded REITs | High | Often high | Medium to high | Medium |
| Private deals and notes | Very high | Often unclear | High | High |
| Collectibles | High | Dealer and auction costs | Medium | Medium to high |
These are general patterns, not ratings of any specific product. For crypto in particular, see our guides to what cryptocurrency is and the crypto risks regulators warn about.
Due diligence checklist
"Due diligence" means doing your homework before you commit. Before buying any alternative:
- Check the seller. Look up the person and firm using official tools. Our guide to checking a financial professional explains FINRA BrokerCheck, the SEC's adviser database and Investor.gov's search.
- Get it in writing. Ask for the offering documents, not just a brochure or slide deck.
- List every fee. Upfront, ongoing, performance and exit fees.
- Know your exit. How and when can you get your money out, and at what cost?
- Understand the engine. How does this make money, in plain words?
- Ask how the seller is paid. Commissions can create conflicts of interest.
- Look for pressure. Deadlines, "limited spots" and secrecy are red flags.
- Test the promise. Any promise of high or guaranteed returns with little risk is a classic warning sign from regulators.
- Size it. Only money you can afford to lose, never borrowed money or emergency savings.
- Get a second opinion. A fee-only fiduciary adviser or CPA who earns nothing from the sale.
A worked example: Dana's "exclusive" note
Dana, a hypothetical 41-year-old, is invited to a dinner seminar about a private note that pays "steady monthly income" backed by real estate. The presenter says spots are limited and the offer closes Friday.
Dana works through the checklist. The seller isn't listed in the official databases. The documents are a glossy brochure, with no clear explanation of how Dana could get money out. The monthly payments are described as fixed regardless of what happens in the property market. Three red flags, and Dana hasn't even reached the fee question.
Dana declines and shares the experience with a fee-only adviser, who notes that consistent returns no matter what markets do are exactly what regulators warn about. Dana spent nothing and kept their savings intact.
If you've already put money into something unusual
Don't panic, and don't throw more money at it to "fix" things. Instead:
- Collect every document, statement and message you've received.
- Ask the seller, in writing, for a full list of fees and the exact steps to withdraw.
- Look up the seller with the official tools mentioned in the checklist.
- Be wary of anyone who contacts you offering to recover losses for an upfront fee.
- If something feels wrong, follow the reporting steps in our guide to spotting investment scams.
Feeling embarrassed is common, and scammers count on it to keep people quiet. Talking it over with someone you trust is a strong first step.
Alternatives and the rest of your money
Before considering any alternative, make sure the basics are covered: an emergency fund, manageable debt and regular retirement saving. If you want something steady for money with a timeline, conservative options like those in our guide to Treasury bonds and I bonds have clear official rules and are bought directly from the government.
Be careful with paid programs that promise access to "the investments the wealthy use". Many sell expensive courses or memberships that steer you into high-fee products. Our guide to whether investing courses are worth it can help you weigh any such offer.
Something to do today
Save the ten-point checklist above somewhere you'll see it, such as a note or a printout. The next time anyone pitches you an unusual investment, go through it line by line before you reply. A legitimate seller will be fine with you taking your time.
Want a structured investing course?
Some people like the structure of a paid program. This button opens a third-party investing course, newsletter or program from one of our advertising partners. Its claims are its own, not ours, and we haven't verified any results it describes. Investing involves risk, including loss of money. Never invest money you can't afford to lose, and weigh any offer against our investment red flags checklist.
See the partner program →We may be paid when you click. The program shown can change. Read its terms before you buy anything. How this works
Frequently asked questions
What counts as an alternative investment?
Generally, anything outside traditional stocks, bonds and cash, such as crypto, precious metals, private real estate deals, private company shares, collectibles, private loans and complex funds. The label covers a very wide range of risk.
Why are alternative investments riskier?
Many are hard to sell, charge higher fees, are complex to understand and have less public information. That combination also makes them attractive to fraudsters.
How do I check if an alternative investment is legitimate?
Look up the seller and firm using official tools, ask for written documents, find out every fee and how you'd get your money out, and talk to a fee-only fiduciary adviser before committing. Walk away from pressure or promised returns.



