What Is an Index Fund?

An index fund is a mutual fund or ETF that tries to match the performance of a market index, such as a list of large US companies, instead of picking investments it thinks will do best. Because it simply follows a set list, an index fund often has lower costs than a fund where managers research and choose holdings. It also spreads your money across everything in the index. But it still rises and falls with that market, so it can lose value.
Index funds come up in nearly every beginner conversation, which is why they're part of our Investing 101 section. This page explains how they work and their trade-offs, not whether you should own one.
First, what's an index?
An index is a list of investments chosen by a set of rules, used to measure how a part of the market is doing. Some track large companies, some small ones, some bonds, some a single industry or country. An index is just a measuring tool, so you can't invest in it directly. An index fund is the product built to copy it.
How index funds work
- The fund picks an index to follow.
- It buys the investments in that index, usually in the same proportions, or a representative sample.
- When the index changes, the fund adjusts to match.
- You own a slice of the whole basket through your fund shares.
The goal is to follow the index, not to do better than it. After fees, an index fund's results will usually be a little behind the index itself.
Why costs are often lower
Index funds don't need a team of analysts searching for the next winner, and they tend to buy and sell less often. Lower expenses can matter a lot over time, because fees are taken out every year no matter how the fund does. Still, "index fund" doesn't automatically mean cheap. Fees vary, so always check the expense ratio. Our guide to mutual funds vs ETFs explains how the two structures index funds can use compare on costs and trading.
Index funds and spreading out risk
A broad index fund can hold hundreds or thousands of investments. If one company falters, it's a small part of the whole. That's diversification in action, explained more fully in our guide to diversification.
There are limits, though. A fund tracking one industry or one country is far less spread out than a broad-market fund. And some broad indexes weight companies by size, so a handful of very large companies can make up a big chunk of the fund.
Index funds compared with picking stocks
| Broad index fund | Picking individual stocks | |
|---|---|---|
| What you own | A whole slice of the market | A handful of chosen companies |
| Research needed | Mainly understanding the fund | Ongoing research on each company |
| Concentration | Spread across many holdings | Tied closely to a few businesses |
| Costs | Expense ratio | Trading costs and your time |
| Outcome | Roughly the market's result, minus fees | Could be better or worse than the market |
Both approaches carry risk. Our guide to stock picking vs index investing digs into concentration risk, research time and costs in more detail.
The main risks of index funds
Following an index doesn't make an investment safe.
- Market risk: when the index falls, so does the fund, with no manager trying to step aside.
- Concentration within the index: big companies may dominate a size-weighted index.
- Narrow-index risk: a sector or theme index can be very volatile.
- Tracking differences: fees and trading mean the fund won't match the index exactly.
- Behavior risk: owning a sensible fund doesn't help if fear leads you to sell at a low point.
All investments carry risk, including the possible loss of the money you invest, and past performance doesn't guarantee future results.
Common myths about index funds
- "Index funds can't lose much." They can fall as far as their index falls, and broad markets have had deep, long declines.
- "All index funds are cheap." Many are low-cost, but fees vary, and some carry higher costs than you might expect.
- "Index funds are boring, so they're safe." A fund following a narrow, fast-moving theme can be anything but calm.
- "Owning one means I'm fully diversified." That depends entirely on which index it follows.
- "It's a set-it-and-forget-it sure thing." Index funds still call for occasional review of your mix, costs and goals.
Where index funds fit in a bigger plan
An index fund is a tool, not a plan. You still have to decide how much of your money goes into stocks, bonds and cash, and that mix matters a great deal. Our guide to asset allocation explains how people think about that mix based on time horizon and comfort with risk.
A hypothetical example
Morgan, 34, wants something simple for long-term savings. They compare two made-up index funds. One tracks a broad stock index with hundreds of companies. The other tracks a narrow technology index. Reading the fact sheets, Morgan notices the narrow fund holds far fewer companies and has swung up and down more in the past, which, as always, says nothing certain about the future. Morgan also compares expense ratios. They decide to talk the choice through with a fee-only fiduciary adviser before acting. This is an illustration of how to compare, not a suggestion of what to buy.
Questions to ask about any index fund
- Which index does it track, and what's in that index?
- How many holdings does it have, and what share do the top ten make up?
- What's the expense ratio?
- How closely has it followed its index, after fees?
- Does it overlap with funds I already own?
Be wary of anyone who markets index funds, or anything else, as a sure path to wealth. No investment approach removes risk. Our guide to free investing resources points to unbiased places to learn more.
Something to do today
If you have a retirement plan, check its investment menu for funds with "index" in the name. For one of them, find which index it tracks and its expense ratio. Write both down. You don't need to change anything; just knowing what's on your menu is a useful step.
Want a structured investing course?
Some people like the structure of a paid program. This button opens a third-party investing course, newsletter or program from one of our advertising partners. Its claims are its own, not ours, and we haven't verified any results it describes. Investing involves risk, including loss of money. Never invest money you can't afford to lose, and weigh any offer against our investment red flags checklist.
See the partner program →We may be paid when you click. The program shown can change. Read its terms before you buy anything. How this works
Frequently asked questions
Can you lose money in an index fund?
Yes. An index fund rises and falls with the index it tracks. If that part of the market drops, the fund drops too, and it can stay down for a long time.
Are all index funds the same?
No. They track different indexes, from broad markets to narrow industries, and they charge different fees. Two funds that sound alike can hold quite different things.
Do index funds have managers?
Yes, but their job is mainly to keep the fund matching its index rather than to pick investments. That usually means less research and trading, which is one reason many index funds have lower costs.



